Sunday, October 16, 2011
Rising to the occasion .
The texts we've been studying that focus on school, were very interesting. I must say my favorite is "I Just Wanna Be Average" because of its story telling and his use of personal experiences, with minimal clouding of the facts. Rose wrote about how students will rise to the occasion; the standards a teacher sets of their students are what the students will come to. I agree with his argument in theory, many students do rise to the occasion, but not all. For example in our school, we have plenty of amazing teachers - we better with our size - and yet there are plenty of kids who slack simply bcuz they don't want to put in the effort. But when Rose mentions his teacher McFarland, that's where the real solution is for these kids. A teacher they can respect and genuinely like. The feelings of disappointing someone who means a lot to you is possibly one of the strongest feelings one can have. If a student honest respects a teacher, letting them down would feel terrible, so the student does their work out of respect. 2 million minutes came from the other approach, it wasn't the teacher's responsibility, it was the student's. The contrast shown was between Asian countries and ourselves in the US. While I understand, much more emphasis is put on school work, mostly math and engineering studies, but this video portrayed a very biased argument. They took top US students and portrayed them as slackers, only showing them with friends and never actually doing their work, while they showed the kids from china and India always cooped in their room doing their homework and never with their friends. In America I think we focus more on being well rounded rather than excelling in one spot, those people are more valued and usually more successful.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I find it ironic how the students who were more well rounded (the Americans) received better opportunities than the Chinese and Indian kids in the end of the movie. I think because they were academically successful in addition to participating in social programs helped much more than just studying to receive a good grade on a test.
ReplyDeleteI agree with the fact that the video showed a biased arguement. They made the US kids seem like they didn't do anything but go play video games, hang out with friends, and go to football games. When they did show the US kids studying they were watching tv and were with a bunch of friends. I wonder if they are trying to make us Americans seems as though we aren't nothing but lazy people who want everything handed to us off of a silver platter.
ReplyDeleteIn the movie they made it seem like the Americans, who were well rounded, were slackers because they did things beside school, unlike the Asians. But since when is being involved in a variety of things wrong? At least here, it is valued.
ReplyDelete